A netizen on Nate Pann drew attention as they made a ranking of fourth-generation female idol groups’ live singing skills based on their objective opinions.
“S: NMIXX
It’s undeniable. They dance hard but their live singing skills are the best
A+: ITZY
They sing live very well but they get nervous sometimes. Without Lia, they can receive a better evaluation
A: StayC, (G)I-DLE and NewJeans
StayC: I think they should rank higher than (G)I-DLE and NewJeans but lower than ITZY, so I put them here. StayC is famous for having good live singing skills but their choreographies are a little too easy. But it is true that they can sing well.
(G)I-DLE: They can’t really dance, and I thought about lowering their level because of Shuhua. I put them here since others are worse.
NewJeans: Their choreographies are the most difficult among fourth-generation groups’ dances. They’re not good at singing live yet but they’ve been performing live all the time and I highly praise their efforts.
B: IVE
I wanted to rank them lower but they’ve been trying to sing live these days. Liz, Yu-jin and Leeseo have always performed live
F: aespa, LE SSERAFIM
These two groups don’t seem to have any intention of performing live. What’s the point of having a spectacular performance if you don’t sing live? In the case of aespa, fans always boast about their vocals but what don’t the members do live stages? Good encores? Singing while dancing is different from singing while standing still. Most idols sing well when they don’t dance”
In response, other netizens commented:
- JYP stans wrote this post because they’re jealous of other female idol groups
- You’re doomed next time JYP stansㅋㅋ
- Just a post written by a JYP stan to bring down aespa, IVE and NewJeans. I guess they will be writing comments praising their own idols’ skills among themselves
- I’m really curious about this. Bunnies really think NewJeans’s choreographies are the most difficult among fourth-generation girl group dances…?
- Seems like SM stans are angry. This person only tells the truth
- You’re right, your flop idols are the best in live singing. No one will listen to them anywayㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ Oopsㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
Source: Nate Pann
